> > 15

ϐ:

ѡ (1) (2) ϐ (3) (4) ϐ : ( ) ( ) ( !). . (5) ϐ / . ϐ / . ϐ : с ѐ .

( (6) 4 1993) ʡ . ϡ Ӂϐ ҡ ҡ ѡ 1994 . : )1995 ,Tarcher .P Jeremy :Angeles Los( Truth about TruthThe ,).ed( Anderson Truett   MCoDzC ,DWC ok .PvC lz G llWN Pw A wV Moߤ qC O@G@C Walter  
A ok oDF Owi Cpiv Dh CdC DC F ,Co vC F MDDVoC 
r p C Ե F .Ckp nd ,PzCk DOhC lz kCp@C C@dC D@C 
.CkCk CqDN Cܵ A F Ckp ypOkr

Dص C ,PvC OzCk @ (7) CCklWO Ov Dok J ok ,Co Ep DV  
(dp C ok) q DV pvDNpv Z .PvC l@z (8) klWODwJ l N DV 
PGw Fo oDFok oCk l ,oDOwV @C ok ,P@vC l@z@Fp@ oD@ ok 
D qC . DN DkC ص DF F Ep DkC þ DF CpklWND@w@J 
Co Dܷ ,koCk C PvC OzCk ,yklWODwK sC oDءF @D@@ 
pv Dܷ DF Cpe .PvC pND qC ,kh D F , oDOhC 
.PzCk Ch oD

pCp Dzp zDJp r F CpklWNDwJ

,o C qC .l HV oC Pd F Co D VN @@ D@@w@D@@  
DF yCwD p qC PzCk Ch oD pv A DF Co CCpklW@ND@w@J 
vDܡOp qC pN ,lCOzCk PGv A pF ,CklWO Ov Dzp 
.V kv SeF hl FDS F

oDFok O ܷ ,lDW ok lClF lCh O ,Ov DDwC ,qpC O@d 
F ,lz DW koCk D pRDN DOzpv pF aA Dlq D PD@F 
,loCl PFDO h CG DDwC ko ok ,D ;l Vo kh ul O@ 
.PvC lvo DA F ,v F v ,DDD qC l Vo vl Do߮vC F 
Z .ϵ yo :lz CqDN Pp G kD Ow p F DJ DA klW@N 
DCN DDp MDGRC F Co ClءCk yo C oCkoD G DDqA 
kD D vDvC pN Mol lvo MDGRC F Dp A Z ,PhD@v@ 
o ϵ F d qC ,[orF pߥN] V PwV D ok ,DFp ,PzCk Co MD@kD@ 
NC kV F olA DFp ,kq lv ok :l DlC joDN Dho .lkp 
خ kq k DA qC ul EDO Dh oC qC a F lOzCk @@@ 
.lkG

C DV F ,DFp CpZ l GN DC ,PvC zo ,DWC DN ,H@Ϯ@  
o o Da ϵ Cpq ,lClD klWO FDwC D q ,lz klWODwJ 
q DFp pOF DOdC ,zDF OzCk p kCpC P F pC .PvC Fp pǿN 
ok pF pw oCk oCk p l ok Co pJ CpǿO DC ,lkl@W@O@ 
GDV Hp Cpq ,lOw klWO pk CpǿO C .l vo Co lA Dk 
(9) krϵ F ,Pw ϵ GDV C lCl lCkoi Co ϵ cԮC F 
l ol Da ,l DCpFPG oDFok aA uDJ F ,Co ϵ DC .PvC 
lCN ϵ ,Pw PG ok pe Ow DV Z DC ,lD@@ ol@ p@F 
lCN rZ PD .koCnF DoDOhC ok pGO GDV CGD@V 
,NCm oDW DzqoC qC A ok ,PvC DV qC lk D@D@@ 
NCkV ,kD p DOC ,MD ,DvDܡOD ,D kV DDܷ@ 
{1}.Pw pGh lpNpF D qC

ipv CpklWNDwJ ?oA o DW F pCp CGDV OD CpF ,xJ  
CwCp Cs ,J Dv k .PvC A pN pOص C .lk@@ P@vk @F 
Dd p r F ,Co qDPCoCp FPGw oD@FD@@v oD@N@@ 
{2}.PvC lAok oD qC oDlD C pN ,kCk oCp VN ko ,CklWODw@J 
p r ϵ GDV qC C ,kF lpF d qC k ϵ C@ @F @ ,Ep@ 
dp ,oD C DF , ;PvC kp Do ,l DV rZ AF ,Co A PvC OzCkpF 
qC J .PvC kDC kpD pߥN Co PG lk D Co Fp ϵ @@ 
ok rpCleO oF ԾC ,Co q ߮voC C DFp ,llV ϵ ClJ 
FDS F ,D qC Co kh oߥ@N (10) N .lOzCk G ,lkF Op D 
k pF OG ,llVDwJ ϵ DC ,kp C A rDV ,@ P@D@v 
C b ԤC l CoC PG qC v C ,PvC PGw OC@ 
Reality Choosing ok , 
l pN lleN OC r qC Oi pwN P ,{PC EDiOC} 
{3}.l DzlDN r lNDGRC Dd lzDF l lCN DA

Dw Co Ov DDwC pC .koA V Co HD C lCN SN @ 
DV F (kh ul O oRD Do߮vC ܷ) d pWJ qC @ o@@N 
qC Z (ϵ ܷ) lkp o ClF klWN Cok ok DDwC CpWJ ,lp@ 
De qC) iv C ;lk D Co DwC Ffv qC pNDF PvC lAok oD@ 
F DD D ϵ pWJ qC O PvDܷ lF (OhDܡOp@@ 
pWJ DC {4}.lpOqD D qC F Co DrZ þ lOC @D@J 
yp bDC ,o C qC , lCOp Co V PvC CpWJ klWNDwJ 
Magazine Chicago phC DoDz qC lV o pF .koA Cp Co pCp@ 
lkF kp IDZ Co (12) Noo koDao qC wǵ {Dz DˡCk W} of University  
.rOw oD ok [orF pߥN]u :kp ԵC

pNeCllz HNpN F kCk Pvk F CN PCo v pWO@ @C qC  
l PN PC C DF Co kh Dl N Cld CpklWNDwJ .lz 
F p ϤC CpklWNDwJ .koCl kV ClzOpnJ GDV b qp@C 
C FPvC D ܷ {5};l Dk C Ck MDGR qC l@ @C qC 
zDF OzCk DجC ClF COF PzCk Ci CGDV Da pk 
C CoClp .PvC lC olZ PwCk lCN pF õ aA Ck Eh C 
D D lzDF OhDz koCk os oDOhDvPC DA C EDF ok @w@ 
pF õ lzDF OzCk oDOhDv Z pC loCk D oDF C ok DC ,loCl 
koCkpF pOF D lV NA k CpklWNDwJ .PvC CND A PhD@z qC 
Ov lF pv DGDV .q!lz h DGDV pz qC HWv :lCr@C@ 
zDd F Co DOC ,oD C DF , loA kp ok Co ;l@@Co@ 
CpVC F O Co DGDV ko J DWA D@N (13) OC pN .lCo 
.l {6} rOvC (14) DǾCuCp D ok v

Cpq ,loA Cp Cp D F oD oOvk CklWODwJ @ @v @C  
ok lk oCp D ko Co phC k DV DkC lOvC Ch 
V qC ,DkC {7}.loA ص F DcԤC d DlN cpV C @@ 
V qC ;lClCo Ov lCOpv DGD pCp Dzp lA p ,G@v 
FD Dzp PvC lz OhDv Dzp Z CpF pF õ lC l ,FDWC 
Ch ,qCkpKF DCo MD C F C qC J , .loCk kV kDO@C 
DCF CpioDN lص ZpC Cpq ;ǿF D wCp phC wϾ F 
oC Co CpklWNDwJ Co kF (17) pl , 
ġpv lDwCp ,PvC DDJ F o lv C C ,C D@F ,P@hD@v 
ZF ,Clok Cs ,lk Co DC qC pm D þ D P .lClz Cp@k 
lCO .kz N CpklWNDwJ iv pNPFCpJ lCN PvC iz ,Cp@Z 
w DpC ok DC ,Pw F CD lwV pk DJoC ok C ǡOhD@v @ 
PdDv pF ,FD ,Da A qCp qC ppv qC Co A PvC l@@ @@ 
.l pq F lCo d klWNDwJ

ǡOhDv Clok :wCp lJ

DFq F Dص DCpklWNDwJ DC ,PvC qoDF DSOvC ko Noo koDa@o  
.ld C qC rADG kD DǡOhDv oDRA loCl MkD kD@v @zo 
kV DFq Co rZ PvC C ϥdDv ǡOhDv Co p@ @C Cl@ok 
texte-hors de pas a y+n il C O DC ,{8}lCh rDFDv p@@ qkoCl@ 
pN l PGSN ,ykh GV C oDz FDS F ,Co (Pw rZ O qC pF) 
DV .lClz DzC oDZk oDz C fN ok pǿ l Cpw Od {9}?P@w@@ 
ok ,yDD pWr ok Co Dv Clok lk D@C D@ @F (18) NJD 
DF kF qDF rV CO DN kqDv oDOp ,mDFq r@@Al@C 
:l PVo ϤC oDz C F lF e k DC ;r oD DFq DO@zo 
lN Co d A C V kDN q....Pw rZ PDF O Dqp ld qC pG@v 
F , Pw oD ok Ow DF Ow uDOv :l ,CkC ok , O ;l 
D DF Co oD pz Cro D Z qC Co kh DGp ,DeC qC e@ 
lk Dl F Co DA qC PDd Mol lCk pnKDC w lD 
HWN DV .kz , qoߩev Dw ܷ ,pk Dw Dw {10}qlzD@F koA ol@F 
wF ǡOhDwv : lk@ yoCr@ (19) volA PC .l CqCkpJrܬ Pw 
GV C DJ .[FCߤ pF DC FCߤ pF oCkD pC] qC ko pNCp 
zDF OzCk D C p ,Dh pF zDF OzCk D p] FPvC pOkr@ 
F Co aA C DF DC zDF ECߤ pFPvC Moߤ C ok ,Dh pF  
koA PV lF Co HϮ C {11}[. kCoC C ok kCoC Mkh D 
oD F pC ,pS C :vpKF kh qC kz HGv Clok pS DwC i@F @ 
C OhDv Cr qC pJ oD F DA ,lA (20) l o߻R lv Cp oDOOvC 
{12}?lzDG oD ok ص koCk DC ,Pw DFC olC DV ok ?lA p 
MoD Z F wp F CO PGD pC :PvC O@ (21) pkpz  
. D lA pF qCppv qA C qC ǡOhDv GF :kF lCh kF

,loCk A qC kp ص oߥN hpF ,ǡOhDv @ koCk oCp@C Cl@ok  
{14}.PvC rpk FPGw ol wv A H Cpq ,{13}PvC CplDN CD@p@F 
(PvC CplDN ol v CoCk DpF C pC) CpZ :vpJ kh qC ol@F 
FDWC GϮ qv CpZ kp kCpC {rN :D} Gv MDC pF Cl@ok 
vPvC ľC DA DF rCplv FPGw Clok lvo p F {15}?ql@ 
pF lص oDOwV C ok ) NJD DV .onF . F FPGw koCk ol 
:l pwN Moߤ lF Co DǡOhDv ol v (oCk N Clok CoA qC C cpz

FPGw F OvDwd PDܵ ...,PvC (22) rzDF plv wϾ pvDNpv Clok lC  
,pk iz :PvC oDwF rCplv FPGw pC PvDwd p . pl@ 
pk ,rvv pk ,[Ow] pk ,DJoC pk ,Ep pk ,rDwDv pk ,p@@k 
{16}.(lFD CkC Pvp) DC rV ,õ pk ,wϾ

ok Clh pC Cpq ,kqDv ,ECnV PDF ,ECnV Co ǡOhDv q C ok pJ  
;lFD oDwFPDGz k F (PCp C DF) ǡOhDv ,kz Ewe rCplv kCl@ 
F lDpF Ozkh qC zD oe kh qC Co D PvC C k p Dخ@ 
qC DǡOhDv pS {17}.lDCpF pk DDwC (Clh p qC) Clh zDF p@k 
C F VN pC koCl HWN DV oN C ,PvC lz oO P@@ 
PCl ǡOhDwv :l Clok) PCl D ol v qC ܷ D qC p@S@ @C 
pF Co oD pC C .lV pF l CoC kh qC DpN CpF ({18}rOvC 
DF lk oCp ok Co DA DDl Cpq ,PvC OhDv ǡ Cl@D@ 
h DA : PvC C Dw DC ;loCk rOv pv lCh wp Dr@@Z 
uDwdC GN qC F {Clh } [pk A] FPGw ǡOhDv Np P@h 
qDNoDv DA ?l oD opJ pv ok Co CkvD CD@@ 
?l P쩾 C poD F kDWC PV ok D F ǡOhDv DkC ko 
DA DF C FPGw ,pk CqCkpJp qC F ,ǡOhDv DiO D@A 
DpJ Dv GV C ok ǡOhDv lO DDO ?loCk ol v l@@D@i@ 
rZ p F l ص Nߵk F lGN Co k lC v lF ql@@p@@ 
k koA Cp Co DC C kpo... ;l@k@ ko mC CqD@N 
,[o rZ lvo Co qC] FPGw vDwdC DF CN ,Co kh oD D@C 
,l Mߵk DA DF Co D ,zDFpk yh DpGh DF lk DW@C,[advent]  
klW o] Cب DOk qC iv C lA p F DC {19}qlzDF opw@ 
z oz MDvDwdC OhDv pGO CpF ,koCk Dew@ kr@ ok [Advent] ,[fw 
qDN :l ܷ l kDOvC {v} ,PpJ ,qDN ,P FPGw CklWO 
qDN D kz Ϸ pC .PvC pOF lzDF pOF Zp Dl@vo Co qC 
rCplv O ? Z PvC lG uDG ok Dz COo DG@O@vC @F 
oߥN ,l@@zD@F (24) D x  
F ߮ oC D oCiغ kol xd ?z Ep ld Z DN Dk l@@ 
Dz DA DC ,lpF D DǡOhDv PvC ClWo llOv Cp@k 
, PvC fC ?lk oD DFpD ݡh DDwC iN ok Co D lCkp  
Cl .PvC oߥN FD D D kClC qC CDOD kClN ,Dh ko p Cp@F 
Ckp oDOhC C h qC þ Cl ,lD MDOC VN eO@w@ 
?loCk DqDF

,rZ p qC F ,ǡOhDv PvC C pOص O DC ,Pw OC vpJ C  
Cpq ,l lN Co D MDN olF lDF pC C ;PvC DFq F VCo Cp@ 
oOvk ,CpoDOhDvDwJ ,CpoDOhDv lo lA DFq F VCo MDp@ 
.lD PFDR rZ k ,F DpV C ok , ?PvC Cp Z PF lF ;Cq 
pOF r DNǡ kz pOF DFq ok CqCkpJp h oߺ Zp C C 
,Wars Linguistic , 
DDJ DvDܡDFq qC qC C DF lz Oz ,{DFq D@@@V} The  
,F :DFq :WO C DF ;PvC kCk Pwz Co D DFq !Ckv :kpnJ 
{20}.p :DvDܡDFq

pRDN DFq F VCo MDp PvC C Cl pv C ok PFDR pC @@k  
kDOvC DsC qC DA N CpF kp CoA MCoߥN pF loCk l@C 
:koCk G Co HϮ C ,CqClC DN C ,NJD {21}.l

.kz DC p DJpk Cr koC ,Dew pF F rW ,ǡOhD@v 
... Pw rZ ǡOhDv ok ....l D G Co CkV pC b kV GV C 
D lDN Co Dw Dk Pw rZ ;l HnN D lN Co k D@k @  
þ lD sr DllJ F DwC oC Dp F l@@ oD@@C 
F lF oDolC Pvk Co Dh G DlkDOC rCMpd Dk@@o 
{22}.loCl oDF DV co oAPz Dko kV

D Ep kD p ok Cpq ,PvC lGp CpF DkC pF C @@  
Dq F pOF (NJD) qD DO (26) lOhDv FPGwv ǡOhDv qllz ݱwv 
C ص .G DlkDOC Dq F DN ,kz DN kD p@ o@C 
ok DwC co DF qpC COp DNol GC D@koC ok Co Cl@ok 
:l (27) F Dv O .lk DV lrOv

D koCk lA Po Do .PvC rOvCo DoCnpRDOv F MDFkC yqoC  
rOvCo DoCnpRDOv C pk DV A pC߱ ,DC ,DzC DV 
,pz pFCpF ok ph lk v lõ C F Co D lp MD@ A qC 
N rA q Z ClFPiv Z PvC pnJDrp Pivp@v oD@@w@F 
{23};Pw

l Co aA DlO ,koCk oDC NCp Z lp ( O F) O  
F lk qDVC C qllz ݱwv . Clok DC ,l oDF CpZ ZF D 
oD F F rOvCo DoCnpRDOv CpF PvC CsC qDoߩ@e@v 
{24}.l kDOC kpF

pOF kz ǡOhDv pOF Zp krϵ .kp ǡOhDv lDF Co DrZ qC CoD@J  
kCk D Co C qC ,kp@ (29) FpWN kh qC  
CoCk N) (31) CkDJ Mv DONpJ qC D (30) ClvC qC PvC CrA kh C 
.PvC OhDܡCo eN rAqDWC ,lCOp MD (FDO O@w@FC 
C CpF kp Cp pOk DF F ;kqDwF qC DN kp Cp Ck@F D@C 
.D (kV) lkDF DFPvC pFCpF {oCllJ} Ϯ (l) kDFGv lk D@ 
: PDok C qC pOF x b .o߬ (32) ok uwk {25}

pNpF CC DOC DA ok Co DDz ,oߤ ,MCoߥN lDF @  
N ,feN ,pwN lz pߥN kD Moߤ F lDA Dqp ld qC pNCp 
p EDF ok õ CvDvC ko l {C DC} .l oDC ,rN DVoDv ,w@N 
oCOvC DD pD koCk lA upOvk ok FD C{C} DvC qC @ 
{26}.koCkpF ykh lz ClhPV ok V F o õ PvC

ϬDF v ,Clok Dkp CoC ok ,D HD C F kr rZ V PwV  
,ݱv Dv l Np qC PvC pk CpD Dkp CoC C .P@vC 
.PvC lA e F DFq p qC oDF C

k DOhC Clok F oCk oDOhC ok Co DW pC C qC Cp@@k  
F Cp CpklWNDwJ qC C F pOF Zp lz pOkr F CԵ 
rp Dw C DF lz Pvk Cpq ,lDF Cp C @@d @F l@d qC 
qC J ,o C qC .PvC FDZ PwZ qClC qC F DDmC ;koCl Cl@D@ 
F lC ,qClC q F Co Czk ,CpklWNDwJ k lF F OhCkp@J 
Dw oD DG NDl v F EDNpJ Cr ,kp qDF Hõ 
,P@vC l@A (33) CpF oD MD qC ok DZ ,Cpq .PvC CpklWNDwJ 
F lk iN Pvok Co D Dq qD Z .lz Dh DGOzC HNp D@@C 
.lk D DivDJ Dh vpJ

ok oC kCk oCl@ (34) xO ,lv C qDA ok ,C qC J : PvC C o߲  
kpNp .Pw oD ok oe rp pk lCOiop Ow@z @ok D@d 
rZ DF rZ b OwF lv olv kp oDnN Pp J Co @i@v (35) DOvC 
ok F Co kiv lk kV Co Dw@C (36) lJ CoqC q.Pw D ok pk 
DܡD PF pNoDlD ,rOvC kp EDNpJ pnJDDDv C@@O@@zA 
kF lF l ok OwFpF rZ pv :PvC C (37) {rGv DDCpZ} Pastures Gre  
phA ok , (38) PvDFo qC O Pw Oz DV ,CpFDF q.PvC lz Do Dd ok 
PwWv :kCk jvDJ l Co D oDqo pF HD C Dd lOvCh ,yCGdD 
V PwV Cpq PvC Cl V PwV C .qC J ok Cl @V  
o oCr , (39) MoDF o D oDOvC F DF ,PC CDq ok C  
MD CrVC PDv NN p DF .TG CpD PvC oD P@vC l@z (40) pZ oCr 
.lAok qDN CCoA DV F FpWN

rWN :PvC klWNDwJ D C ;z VC A DF lDF PvC ǡ D @C  
a ,Cl Mop .lkDܵ pv pF pl DF CrVC F lC @l@q 
) CklWODwJ ,lk ECn Xo PvC kp oDOp Co D ,lܡ CoD@F 
D (qlKF ÿv :kp N Pw@@ (41) pOvo߾ .C .C oDlF Dz 
DOhC Dkp CoC ,pOF DOww oCk qD ClF D aA l 
.PvC (DA qC zD rCqo DlCpJ ,DDpJ ,DzDJp ) pO@F 
Co Dkh p p DOVC Drq qC Cl oC OwCN p@C 
DF DCk lD lk Co DǡOhDv k D qC DFPpv D@F 
DA ok lCDDV V PwV ok vCpv lk v A F v C qC C 
{27}.lAok oD qC lkv pOF NDGSF FCph lC

CpklWNDwJ F k jvDJ

lq DGDV .I

F lF C qC , VN CpklWNDwJ k lF F ,C  
D O {Oo kD qC P@d} TruthForgotten ok Co aA kD kp 
DDFq NDC DD DOhC pq ok C A ;p p@ 
GCl@FD@ (42) rpv loCk pl DF ,DV orF DkC ܷ ,pF co  
,HNpN xǵ F ,kp kld lleN G Co CpklWNDwJ e v {28}.Pw pO 
DGDV F DDwC Co k DkC v C k oCp T@e@F ko@ 
olC Od loCk kV ,lpnKDC kDOC FD DGDV ,llqD@ 
.oCl aA pF lOvC CpF ClZ DW OGC yoCr zpF

lpCp NDp ܷ lCPCoCp D GDV ,Dzp GV qC ,DkC Z  
Co CpklWNDwJ lV lõ lCN k DO oC D Pd ED@F ok 
.lpnKF lCo Ov lFpv ,Oo o ,DPCoCp D DGDV  
pDd d lDz C ;rOvC DW klWN rApev kov PvC O@ (43) UpV 
,C Vok ok ,lFD p Co DGDV lV CklWODwJ C Cpq ,PvC l 
p Dp ,oD C poD F DF {29}.PvDA DOVC DlDJ HGv @F 
qC ; DN koCk op pOF k (loA k ) loCn @C p@F Co 
DOVC ϵ CpkpoD DF p C lqo оDN PwF O C 
DqD lDJ Dq DN þ DkD C FPvC D koCk MD@D@@ 
Cz ܷ kص lF PvC C pOص O DC {30},loApF Co DOVC 
ClZ liF M yCDN Oop kh ok Dd ok Co pF co ,A kl F ,k 
pO Х kص lF DF ) lq ߥh iz lF O .kz C V@N ko@ 
,r õ .kF lCi oCzk l DGDV oD ,kz MD@G@RC (koCk 
õ D@@F ,l@oCk (44) DF F qD ,lq MCkV qClC FPvok 
ol Zp C zo PdCp Cr ;PvC ,oC qC ܷ ,A GDV 
õ ܷ} k C D Ci ,Ck PDd ok rV .yDF lzDF F D  
Ե .iF kGF Co Ci C DN z OvJ D ,Pw {yCGD@V 
,kDd koC ok , ,DFkh DF ,DܷF uDwdC qC lNoDG DD Ci 
lq PvC C EϮ Ci e .PvDzA Eh DA DF klWNDwJ ,ECpC 
F D Mol ,PvC D Ci lvo p F O .lzDF oCkDܷ D@V  
.lDvo DCN qC oAPz CGNp F Co C kz pqCpv i@z ok 
ܬDFPDN pC C ,koCk ϷN kV F lCk {PDd A ok}  
x {31}.PvC D {Ow} PDN DF Cpq ,PvC lp koA llJ 
Co zDFpk CpD Cpq ,l peN koCqA MlF Co DǡOhDv @ @ 
D lCN ,PvC Z ,Clh Cpq ,l Co A DC Dܷ F ;l 
CpZ ,PvC kp F pe CpCp Clh pCp DWA qC DC .lzDF rZ 
DOzC Clh DN l ۷ ,kz Dz lzDF OzCk kV Co rkFplv p@ 
kp oDOhC ok lCN DV oCl A zDF pk F MD pFPvC Cl@h 
.kz kCk

ϷN uDwdC C klWODwJ DClC ,C , kpF D w koCk DOdC  
klWODwJ DClC , .l ol koCk CqoC {kA F} k Co D 
MDd lCkCk qDVC lCkp kh oDz Co rDWv ,lklWN DRoC ,r 
,CpGw CpϮ .lk oCp DCPeN Co OhDzkV MDd DOVC 
yph ;liF co F PvC Nol Ϯ pC p .loCk PGS DGV ,k p 
,PvCoCl yp CpGw DC .krF ClF lCN Mol A PvC pW@e@N 
GV ,lFD ߿N DOVC MDd DVp .PvC A oDN GV oD@@CY@J 
VN ko (CoCl ܷ) CpGw zo GV (pWeN ܷ) CpϮ @oD@N 
k p ok .lCCp k A DOVC D GV k C CpZ ,lz@ @C 
Ewe PC l oC k C qC Co D FDqoC kص kDFC ,ko@ 
.lߡ C PϿ ko F pC ,lz

lpnKDC DGDV .II

DGDV DC OGC ,DA DC F DGDV F qD qC on@ ok  
k DkC C .Co DopJDo DqCkpKDh ,oCk p l ok Co pGO 
F ,PvC oDN ok ϤC CpklWNDwJ DF koCk upOvk DF Z F pF õ  
lV PCo DF lq DGDV C ܷ k G DkC @ @e@ D@@ 
.PzCk oD CpklWNDwJ

l lOvC kqDv OG pFPkle pF Co kh ϤC CpklWNDwJ  
CCi k C D ,lOw kleD pC koD pd kle @@ @Z 
PvC DOCp kz C PϿ ko Oww C ok aA .kF lCN@@ 
pOD ok k .A DDN ,DeC ,HNCp ܷ ;lk DW DClFPkle 
C qC ,Pkle PvC p ,koCk @ (46) DD , (45) DOC ,Dܾ DF ,kh UoCl 
O C lCN CpklWNDwJ .lzDF OzCk kV D ,PvC Pkle Td 
O C ܷ ,lFDok r Co DN C pk GV lCN C D ,lFDok Co 
:D} DV ,qC @@ , (48) PzpvCkF , (47) NA ,Clh Moߤ CpnJ Pkle Co 
.PvClh koCk kV Zp ,koCk kV Clh þ .PvC (49) {D DwC

FA oDF .qD Pvk SN F o C qC ,loCzk D D C  
CkN pC D .lFA , ,k p DC ,Pw uDC lV pF D@C qC 
Ozo Ozo A qC P p xKv kzP P Pwi oߥN Co uo qC kleD@ 
pOZ qDF ,kkp llJD C DN kz pOZ pOZ A Ozo p@ kkp@ 
DlC G C koCk k do w CpF .PvC uo D@@O@zo A om 
Pr ,Clh DF D OvJ OhDv m F okDGO Td qC ,lCN@ 
qC PvD TeF ko Է PvC CO C COv@J p@ .l@@zD@F 
CklWODwJ CpN yp F Co Dw CklWODwJ .koCk COp@@ 
DkC C F O Co DA lp CrOvC F loCk CpOC õ FPG@w@ 
lpF Clh ١Z qC oC F lp UC DWClF DN lCN DDwC l 
,lCDwC DF DGDV .PvC PD M lF D Ϯ ϵ @ 
F ,loDqDv DDwC DpǾ qp DF DGDV PvDܷ lF HϮ@ @C 
,DWC ok ,DC .koCk uDJ Co lpJ A pǾ qp lpJ GDV e D@ 
.DءZ DF ,F DءZ aok qC v :PvC HD CpZ @Z@F (50) F p 
CC pDv Clh ,F C F D Co ,MCkV Cܵ F ,DV C 
DN qp D ok ,C DF koCl MDD lF pk D F MCkV 
.lzDF OzCk kV PvokD Pvok ,pNlF pOF DN qp ,DV qC DDw@C 
DzkClN ,PvC CCp Pvok DCo DzPvok Co ,pNPC Dܷ@ @F 
ok kV MDOhC :koCk DOC kF DwC Oi Dd Dz PvC D@ 
DWC ok DC ,PvC HϮ C qC pءZ DV orF NDC DD@@ 
,lFD lCC MDDGO@zC @ P@vC @C @O@@ 
.PvC MDDGOzC C qC CpklWNDwJ

DOzo xǵ .lzDF D koCl r ,lzDF pGO C Cp@F ,@@ l@k  
Co D Ozo C D ,lzDF Ci Dz p Dd AF ,lCN@ (51) DD 
qC DD A þ ,pOk DF F PvC C D DD þ ,lk D D@k 
lq Clkph COF DN k DiN PvC q @C @D@ 
.lA CoC kl ok DPCoCp

DF pk t p qC F CklWODwJ vDܡOp qC D@@@t@ A  
,PvC lvo ZJ ld @F @ (52) CCpp :lCk C loCk oDN DzDpF 
(53) .PD qC lDGõ OCp

F ,Oi DCq qC CpFDF ,Oi C qC D fC PC C O@  
,Co DrZ CN D ,xJ : kz lGN rV ФC C F p D@@V 
DwC Cq , PD kr ok .kz YJ Cpp ,vDܡF ,lOw C ok D@Z 
O ;PzCk qDF DwC DzC PhDz qC Co D kF (m M ܷ) D 
,lz krC ص D C F DFq ,Dq ,p ,OhDܡCo DD 
Cp ,CpioDN ,p Cp@G@w@ , (54) CpDOhDv ,HNpOF 
PϿ A qC ,DzC C ok ,rV Cpp aA .lA ФDd DFq @p@ 
DN e F , PvC C rOw lp Dp C iN PvC C kqo@ 
Z lF .lk rN DDV C F Co Dp vDܡF Co D ,CqCl@C 
D ,١Z p qC .kz N z kh (CqDw O F) rOzCkpGv p ,OhD@z 
lk D ФDd ODok DNC qC DN hpaF DNC kpCkp lDF þ 
kh lCN pd ݾ PvC oCrFC õ DC ;lOw p rV rZ D Dp@ 
F ,} lk DV qpk DDwC D衿 olv ,{DDFqwC} D pG@N @F ,Co 
D衿 O {32}.{koCnF qpk DDwC DV Gv ,DDFqvoD D pG@@N 
ok ,O ;o pNCp p CpGw qC ,lzDF DDF F ϷO@ 
C O .o pNCp b D CpioDN qC oAok Co D衿 ,HvD@ 
DlkoDnN lqCkpJ CrOvC F qDF kz DpDh CklWODwJ F O 
ko ok) D ,lo pF khPvJ qC lCN ll C F l @O@ Co 
oߥN k p .l Ppd Ozm oCkC Eߤ F lz oCv pOJ@@ p@F (D@q 
DC HDV ,oD C DF , lk D ECߤD PV ok Co kh D De@ 
PvC C F ,o pF kh qC Pw C Cpp lF .loCn p Co 
lDrF FDPvk DrZ F ߺ oߺ olA z p kh ok @ 
vpJ F .koCl Ե ߺ oߺ F CpklWNDwJ .lrp pw D @Z qC 
Dpz pFCpF ok ,{Oo D@ qC p@@z} City Soft ok , (55) Fo DNDDV  
lD D DN lvpF c߮v pq F lCN Z :C A l klWODwJ 
zDJp F Z ,CpklWNDwKv :lk jvDJ (56) oD lk ?lk iN Co ϤC 
{33}.lq N vpJ C EDF ok DN qC pw ,PvC kCk Do pd ldF oClDJD 

EDF ok Co PD lõ lC OD C .lDGõ lC O@D@ D@C  
{34}.kqClC qC ,DV ,Clh , :loCk kV DA qC DN @v @ , (57) DlC 
DC ,loCl oDzC FD uwe Cl loCk D DF Co MDN C Dl@C 
,krpF uCd Z qC lzDF OzCk Cl (a) , kz C qC D pC C 
,DV ko ok .pGF DV F Co DA oDFok pǿN DF D (b) ,C qC D  
DV F CpvPvDPCoCp VN ko ߨ ,sC C pCp Dܷ @F  
qC ,PvC pD Cp D pC p ,D F oDzC CpF ,C ܷ@ r@kp@F 
D pC C . PC qC F Co CkDOvC D FDWC D@Fq 
pk rZ p D ,OD@ (60) DN , (59) pFDp , (58) DOv ,PC Co 
D pC C pnJD oDFok DrZ CklWODwJ pC .lDF lCh 
, (61) CoDDz ,uwk lD CGv DCkGClFD qC @ l@@Cl@F 
p ok qCo lCOF A qC pO PvC C ,lzDF lz M@ (62) DVp 
.PwZ C lF D F Dep Dϵ oDGϬ DA qC D F .lDF 
fv ok lA koC CNDC DD pF þ DA Dl pC ,pk v qC 
C qC ,Dl C C Pwi .kp oDzC lDF O k F ,lD O FDWC 
Co DA ,DD dp ok , DOv lCOp D Co ClC Td 
qC ,Dl C C k .lpSF ,lCOhDv Gw kp Dv @C @Vok qC 
,pl ;lvo DOv A Pd ld F ,l CkC Co FDWC oC d Td C 
C Vok k DO kV lF .lO p C qC Cl@ok , (63) DOO 
Co rN MDC NDC DD Oi oߤ laJ W ,kDOCD@V 
Co F CpF Gv MDC GCp õ k߷ .lOw pnKDC lqD@v@ 
lCN C PdDv qC V D oߥN lFPvC lz lN cp A OhClC 
Oo pNCp F Co k iN koCl kV rZ oߥN Z lF Cpq ,kz qDA 
{rN } Hv q pz kDOCDV FDWC MDC .l Mߵk OwV PG@v  
.PvC

,Ov Gv Dp qC .kp qDF DD D Ozo x@ @F C@@e@  
qC , ;lOw A DSC lCD pC v F D DCo ol A DGDV 
Co C Dz lCN DG Noߤ D F lzDF kD lCN ,Td @C 
Co Dz lCh ?lCh Z DG qC CklWODwJ C lF lk D@@ 
Z qC lk mC D F CklWODwJ DC .l N Co A ?l @@N 
.lCkp D A olv D ,qlCkp oDhDvPd kh F CpZ ,rF k DrZ 
l DܵpO ߤC CkCpJ CpGO pFDN MDdԮC @C qC gA) {35} 
Co oAo pǾ lO ok qC Co kh Ckpo O ,DOO@ .(qo 
klWN qC D DOC ,kp N Dܷ FPd qC DOC phDO ok @F 
F CklWODwJ ߻k r DWC ok .kCk pGh JDJ Co klWNDw@J @F 
Co Pd C F rAHN u Cpq ,l PdCr kDWC DOVC o@C 
C qC C F lk v Co CklWODwJ l p pk DizC d @F 
qC ,oD C DF , ;lܡFPvk F ,lzDF kCp D Ϯ Pd pC ,ߥiC@@ 
DWA .A lF ,PvC oDCpnJDh q pzPd lqo PϿ PC C 
{kz pe ܷ@} l@@ deviate A qC w DN Pw oD ok C(Pd ,Co ) via  
{36}.koCl Dܷ DGOzC

loCk kV pGO DGDV .III

Cld DkC FPGD ,CpklWNDwJ PCo v pF uǷ DC D op@ D@F 
kpoDF DGDV qpC D l yoCr Dp vo Cp @C 
DF Moߤ lF Co HϮ C {Eh D@V} Society GoodThe Dܥ qC .oCl 
{37}. N Z Ck oCl C Dv :l

,kp D CpklWNDwJ pNDlpJ PCo k ok PwDF Dd @ ok  
,Pw F N ,ФC ok ,Z ,Ch Cld C ,lܨoDN ok pF co DF Cp@Z 
lN cpV ld DN CN Co N C ,C DF .koA J CC ǡ@ 
Ep Cpǿzo F ,Ch Cld iz O ok ,qDv ,oCl C D C ok .kp@ 
lCkp pk DlDJ klWN Co Dõ DmC Dw .koCk oD@zC 
lq l DzoDOhC ok Dzk DFDO D DF FDwC D@@ 
.l

ko ԤC pC ,D lpnKF lCkDA ) lV CklWODwJ @ @l@k  
Co k DFDO (lzDF kDOC ko HN pv qC lDF lDCϵ ,lzDF kD@O@C 
UDA CpkDF .loCk ClCrCpF DDD C F l @O@ 
DN ,klWODwJ Cܵ F ,Dzkh PvC C lFDok aA ;PvC DA @C 
pOص vDv oD鲾De Cpq .lCkF CpkDF DF TD@F l@d @Z 
oD鲾De CoClOvDv ,CpkDF lk pOص .Pw CpkDFP@D 
PvC oDCYJ CpGw llN ,l kDO@vC k@h k@v @F A qC 
DOVC DlDJ DCpG C r DWC ok .koCk D ok CpklWNDwJ 
qC Co DDGOvC loCk l koCk CqoC k CܬDF MDW p@F Co 
.l s s oC

DOVC PDF F ߻k ,lkp p lV ϤC CpklWNDwJ p@C  
D PD wN ,lCOhClC D DV F DCpklWNDwJ C ,l@q 
pC C DlDJ qC ;lk OhDzkV pǿN F okD Co k@h qD@F 
CCp CpOzC V Z k Dzp lk ,Dd A ok , kF@ @C 
lص lk DV ok ok Co p k DV Dzp C :C .loCk 
oDwFPDGz HϮ C DF l CoC rZ vDܡD .PvC p@D@ 
(65) DqDvoDzA qC a pF { vDܡD@@ ok} (64) oDN kD Cpq ,koCk 
kD qC N 70u :PvC C D N qp qpC ,l pRC FpWN @@ 
ܷ DrZ F qC om þ ,Ck oDN kD qC N 30 DGpN ,kpv oD@N 
DkC pk ,C DF {38}.PvC iN FD ϵ DoCrC CpF @ CkD@ qC 
Z) Cpq ,PvC OD CtJ FpWN ϵ ok k DvDܡD D@@VC 
pD DV {C A } ;PvC ϵ C upOvk qC pNCp (PvC oClzqoC @ 
,lCp DV qC pNlzqoC pOC A MDp MDdDv F ,koCk PC þ  
.PvDA EDNqDF þ

orF pWq] qC kD PvC OCo Ov DvDܡD pOCl DV C  
MCkV qC ,GNCp wv D ok , PvC lA Cp NDd qC [Ow 
, C pˡtJ pNOwVpF ;lFD kClOC kV pOD DN D@ 
,DV p ok ,DOip pOF ,lW lv phCC DOv l , (66) V oNoA 
Co A krϵ O DN ܷ ,qlOzCk G CpZ ZF {Co Ow orF pW@q} 
PvC krC r Co HϮ C V F Cp@hC (67) pG {39}.PhClCpF 
pǾ Dh pOorF D ...koCk DN UCo z Dav [Ow orF pW@q] 
DZ A UCo z DhPvC kp o pF joDN ok PvC kp F pe@ 
DN pOk DPvC kp X X Co õ , d Dܷ F , PvC @@ 
{40}q.PvC OvJ o F C D EDF ok DN PvC kp F pe

WO

F ,kh DPCoCp FDWC NDC DOdDv qC DkC kDܡJ @C  
÷D ol D loCkpFPvk ,loCk pl DF CGClFD DODGz k@v 
DODGz DN lppFPvJ kh lF qC CiF D@D@w@C qC @ P@vC 
Cr C ,k ϵ Cr pC DC .kz FDOA DDl@G@C@i@O@vC 
EZoDZ ok ,lOwCN DkC ,l p PwCN ,k CpklWND@w@J 
Plh ok ,lzDF oCkohpF {DVC pOF } 쥿N pO qC OCoCp@ 
,l Owr ph zh F Gw ,koCk D DF lq Co Dz D@C 
qC lA Cp PDF ok OC DV qC XCo C P qClC D @F 
e D F D ;lv pz OC r ClءCk ص D koC@ 
.lkF v pz ϵ GDV PCoCp ok Ho ϵ MDp (klWN Cok ok) 

D vDz Co w Cpq ,lz pODv V kCk go CC Z p@C  
PvC NCp qC pNlVoC A P DV [kh] F VCo klWNDwJ p @ l@@ 
,l kp kh Oo ok oCq MCp F CklWODwJ .l CoC DV DkC 
õ l D o C qC F ,loCk Pvk Co D@A @ o A qC @ 
.l eN D pF Co MCp C qpC DwC PioDN

.Pw oD ok eN Z PvC C MCoDC ϤC O

(68) qCpv DˡCk

VpO DOzCkkD

.k fN 쥿OF Co A o C qC ;lCkpG J Dص O C @F .{1}  
Dܷ C lAok Cl F D ,kF ylC D DOvDh ,klWN p uD@ 
G DDqA Z qC rZ z ,kle DOdDv ok ϵ lCN ٺoϵ , lz  
:lV pF CpD oN qC Dok DZ ,ko olF ϵ oCkoD

DzqoC F DC ,kqCkpKF lCN oCrFC N DzqoC F ϵ .DzqoC .a  
.lCN oDW NCm

D DF DC ,lzDF OzCk oD pv lCN Op D DF ϵ .D@@ .b  
(?PwZ lq Dܷ) D D DF D ,(?PvC oCkDܷ wC ϵ DA) kV 
.lCN

,lzDF OzCk oD pv lCN Owq MCkV lؾl teleonomy DF ϵ .ClC .c  
.lCN ,D ϵ, teleology DF DC

. MD ok DC ,PvC Pvk pZ MD ok ϵ .MD .d

oDOo q Dk CpD MCkV DF ϵ .kD p pD@ o@C .e <  
COF DN lCwDܻ DCl rOw A kCpF MDpd S) lCkD@ 
pD MCkV pk DF DC lzDF OzCk oD pv lCN ,(kp D@V@N 
.lCN

Pkle C .lzDF OzCk kV NCkV Z pC ,D qC pNpF MCk@V@ .f <  
lzD d Co Dw F ,loCk kV D qC pOorF NCkV l MD@G@RC 
l ϵ l ClVC l :D} rOw l F F lv Cpq ,koCn @D@F 
{kVC

C ܷ@P@vC kp@ @CoC (Gellner Ernest) ,p PwoC pk pN .{2}  
p qC pNpF CpGw@ } Alle uber relativismus qC PvC MoDG CpklWNDwJ 
Religion and Reason ,Postmodernism (1992 ,Routledge :,FDO qC 40 e ok ,{r@Z 
Pw CpGw DC ,kz V oDN pN DFPD okYork New)  
lCOF oD p FPvk CklWODwJ o C qC ,lzDF DvA oD A qC Dk 
(Geertz ,xNp ko߿ rCpGw l lv .lrpKF HwZpF C qC DN l@q@ 
wv 1987 Pw p@hA qo ok @ @D@ (shirt-T) ,Mpz N .PvDl lDzClifford)  
F DV @ (Berkeley) ,pF ok (Institute NEH) ,DwC ϵ CpF MD 
lz d koh olFp CpCk o pF ,DA PԵ .PvDܷ C D koh ١@Z 
bJ l DF ,lCN CklWODwJ .r ev CpGwv :kF C ,kF 
O F Dܷ pC DC ,l k kh qC Co Dh DCpGw ,ko@h ED@N  
CN d BDF Oi z D ,Pw oD ok OCp b PvC OwFC 
pF ,o C qC , loCk PDi pWO C DF CklWODwJ ,@ .kp@ 
,oDN pN ܷ ,DA kh pN DF p DJ DA qC p pN 
.pv

.)1989 ,Shambala :Shaftsbury and Boston( Reality Choosing ,Wallace Alan

.Pw DDwC qC pO첵 DrZ Dd FpWN ϵ ok Cvok EDO b .{4}  
;Pw pOF DwV Mol qC oCkohpF pNSWC첵 DrZ Dd ,O@G@C 
G qC DO쩾 Dz ,qpNpGv sC D Dܷ F Pw rZ Dd DC 
.lzDF pNpF D qC ,kz r MkDv ,Pdo ,õ

:lw O l DF Co ϤC C CoClp p oD l@@k .{5}  
ldC kqDF Ckv CN D {C pF} loCk lDN DCpklWNDwK@v 
Ck CrVC rF , rF Co DV D CopKF pv ok Co D@@V qC 
q. pߥN ,pOC

.)52.p ,]1990 ,Blackwell :UK Oxford and MA Cambridge[ Postmodernity of Condition (  
The

.1987 February 20 ,Supplement ,u Modernity fro q ,Eagleton Terry .}6{  
Literary Times

Clص ,DkC C ok ,k CpklWNDwJ D kDN OhDv OwVpF Cp@F .{7}  
CkCk oCp D l ko pq EDO ok Co DkC D kV MDO@hC 
:C

.)1992 ,House Paragon :York New( Religions World on Essays :Smith Huston ,).ed(  
Byrant Darrol

ok .{8}

.24-123.pp ,)1984 ,Press University Manchester :Manchester( Thinkers Conti  
Contemporary with Dialogue ,Kearney Richard

rZ V C Dܷ qDF DN CiF CCp DOz l@D@F .{9}  
281.p ,)1986 ,Press University EDO MDVol G pF Dܷ.l {pDF} Pw 
rZ bv PvC @CHarvard :Cambridge( Mirror the of Tain The Gasch Rodolphe  
C kh ;qlzDF OzCk iGODo ,phA k lD ,lCN O qC p@F 
Pw O qC pF rZ Pw HϮ C DF qp pNkDv r V 
.koCk V Dܷ þ O A l N

.453.p ,cit.op .Philosophy andFaith, Theology and Derrida :Alterity about News .}10{  
Good ,Caputo John

.87.p ,)1990 ,Row and Harper :Francisco San( Be to Used It What Isn|t Reality ,.}11{  
Anderson Walt

Dk {C ok} FD yrApeN ld lF DN aBv ,pk D@@F @F .{12}  
.(.)632.p ,1994 ,qCOe pFCpF ok Gv qC PvC DCpoDOhDvDwJ @D@D@A 
Autumn ,Scholar American The, Code Poststructuralist the on Notes ,Slingerland  
Edward)

:F lpF .{13}

.33-120.pp ,)1988( 2 Parle Qui ,Holms Brian by translated, Yes of Number A  
Jacques

.124.p ,cit .op ,kearney Richard :ok .{14}

Zp Gv MDDv l@, 458.p ,.cit .op ok ,Clok p qC NJD DV .{15}  
q.l FDWC GϮ qDF lzDF Gv ol

.ibid ,Caputo John .}16{

Pw lO Clw Clok ZpDv .lk wF Co DGNoC C NJD@ .{17}  
Co yClC , p F ,koCl Ck MCp ,Ck DW@A D@N , 
ld DN ,rACpC llzPvDwd F ,ul EDO qC zD P@@vD@w@d 
pk NDGD v F ,PvC kCk v pk iz DOvCh v F CCp@ 
koCl Cl D lCkp pF D lCOzCn pF pk iz ,koCk D qC 
.(466.p ,.ibid) ,rOvC N DPr lD ,lFD Cz y D

.15-14.pp u ,Authority of Foundation Mystical .}18{  
,]1992 ,Routledge :York New[ Carlson Gray David and ,Rosenfeld Michel ,Cornell  
Drucilla .ed( Justice of Possibility the and Deconstruction in

.457 ,454.p ,.ibid ,Captuo John .}19{

.49.p ,1994 ,February/January ,Sciences The in ,)1994 ,Press University :ok .{20}  
Oxford :York New and Oxford( Wars Liguistics The ,Harris Allen Randy of review  
Berreby|s David

ok, (Association Philosophical American the) ,wϾ DpC WC Pw@ ok .{21}  
CkD Noo koDao kF O A lA J rCDW e ,1980 pGD@vk 
eN DA ok v koC qC l CoC D DN PzCn oD PeN Co kh 
kCk CrC wC ϵ qC Co D wC ϵ p DG EDF ok wϾ 
A P , p F ,C ,PvC lD ECVF C leN ,oDwF D F q.lzD@F 
oDOwV C VN ko Dw F Co kh .F ǡOhDv DF Co leN D P@vC 
DJ Pw MoDG Od k HO ok ,S ,DA :vpJ kl@e@ 
Ddo Cpw koCk Clok DNoD poD F DF ,COF Co yC@k 
?liF pOF ص ,lCOzCl ,oDC p ߬ ok ,k

.463.p ,.cit.op ,Caputo John .}22{

.97 .p ,)1994 ,Viking :York New( Up Adds All It ,Bellow Saul .}23{

Dq pǾ DoDF qC ,kz DNpF pFCpF ok ,yo qC DOv @C .{24}  
VO , ,kDOC lz C ݱv ko qDoߩev , e D ok .PvD@ 
z خ DN voC Co DF H PvDF pDv DC .kz DǡOhDv yo 
Co DF H Co aA PvC q ,C OvCo PvC pC D@F @ 
MDGRC ,Ow p e F , PvC DܷF iv C ,voC r l voC 
qlzDF kz p lCN kzPvC ϵ wd ߾ oC F ϵ @ l@@@ 
(Schuon Frithjof Cz Op)

.153.p ,)1992( 2.No ,24.Vol ,Psychology Transpersonal of Journal The ,Buddhism .}25{  
andPsychotherapy in Self of Lack The :Void the Avoiding ,Loy David

.6,7.pp ,)1987 ,Press Paulist :York New( Dionysius-Pseudo to Preface ,Roques .}26{  
Rene

.PvC krC lDN

F} kCk qDVC ...PvDoDOhDv kp qDF kp z ǡOhDv D@W@v .{27}  
qC koCk ond pF Co D ǡOhDv .l ص {pN} qDF ... pNCkCqA DN {Dr@@Z 
ok Co rZ oD C Cpq , oߥe ,DeC qC e F ,{Co Dr@Z} @@@C 
.(57-456.pp ,.cit.op ,,qkz kCqA DN l N koCk uGe DD oCkoDZ 
lzDF OvpJkCt C pC Z : qDF O G Co COCaputo)  
PvC C Dغ ,l d F pD C lF l qC DN lz@@ 
?kz kCqA ,loA kh zPeN r Co OvpJkCt

.)1992/1976 , World the of Vision Common The .}28{  
Francisco San :Harper( Religions s

DF ,oCD HW e F ,k DV V J ok ,poDطOvC D@D@J .{29}  
D z F ,PwCN xoD .lz O@i@@Aok (Marx) ,xoD ݱv Np 
Pd oCkDpv CoClp DrZ qC oDwF lk D ,CllD@O@ 
hC DC ,PvC DA NDG D EDNqDF ܷ slC ,C ok ,loDC@ 
lOzClJ {} oCkDpv CoClp Z lkDOCok ЬDF D C @F C 
F oDF xJ ,lOpv Co kp {} PvC Od DDkC ko Pd @ 
.Pw GϬv lzDG (Descartes) ,MoDk pC .lzDF FpvPϵ lDF Pd 
e F Co kh ݱv Np xoD Cpq ,rArܬ p PvC @Co @C  
,C DF .l oC ,PwCk Co A ,ykh Dlk CpF Co Co DN koA 
DF) PGD ,lOp J ok Ow MDd p p lOzCk M Dlܾp@N 
Pd F kDOC lloz kh DloAllJ pF (Cp@@k , (Freud) ,lp ,a 
.lkp Pwv F Co

pC ,P C ,PvC ,PvC ϵ ld DN ,ϵ C : DC ب CO@  
oDwF MD Pw P D ,lzDG pCp PDF l ةN OD@F 
;pF p Co O k C l lDF Dp ,oDOwV C ok ,DC ,lC 
.oCl Co DA qC Dk DW

PvC C qC Dd oCk Co xNp ko߿ yoCr ,lD@J ED@F ok .{30}  
F ,lzDF OzCl CGClFD {b} DDwC PwDe Dî ZpD@v 
).338.p ,]1957[ Review Antioch ,q(rzDF kohpFDDwC Z F lvo p 
Symbols Sacred of Analysis the and View-World ,Ethos

.DC C ok D C uDwdC :Dp Dd qC DOO pN .{31}

.l oDC klWODwJ DvDܡDwC PvC rZ D Dk C ,OG@C .{32}  
qDA pk Dp CC qC ԬC Hw CpF z Cܵ F Cϵ Ozo 
CpOC DF DvDܡDwC Է .PvC cp C DC l ypm pǾ C l@z 
D Co khPlV lCPC pD ok þ pk CC F VCo rNDCv C @F 
oh ok ,oDO ,p F OwFC ,pOCCk ,DF lD O .lk@ 
,lz oDo ,lNDGSF qClC D F ,DvDܡDwC lD DF ,lCǡO@hD@v 
ok DJ z F Dw ?loApF lCOF pǿO Dr PvC lC Cl@ 
pk EDF ok CN ;l kh DF kq pd F ,PGD ,DzoD loCn Co 
qC DN lz DDlzDqA DA kh DA ok CCl EoDW@N qC 
.PvC Pwz F e C qC PvC dp C ,lA pF kh DJ

.59.p ,.cit.op ,Harvey David .}33{

lCOD Fo @ C (Scharlemann Robert) ,DoDz MpFCo oClC .{34}  
.kp DpDh TeF DF Co lDGõ

.(]1993 ,,q,PvD p pǾ DpV pNk P F ev ,PvC Pd .{35}  
Press California of University :Berkeley[ Critics His andFreud ,Robinson Paul)

)1994 ,House Paragon :York :pq OhDܡFDO MDi DF , MpFCo EDO@ .{36}  
New( WorldPlularistic a in Values Absolute for Searching :Maze Moral the Through , 
.l DF ClƸD e F Co O CKane Robert

)1991 ,Knopf :York EDO Dܥ qC @, (Madse ,vl koDao kCp .{37}  
.PvC l pO oDOvok ok,New( al et Bellah Robert ,Society GoodThe

.16A ,1992 October 1 ,Chronicle Francisco San .}38{

.59.p ,)1936 ,Press University Harvard :Cambridge( Being of Chain Great The ,.}39{  
Lovejoy Arthur

:l lDN Co V O@@ @C ED@F ok (Cassirer Ernest) ,opvD PwoC  
(9.p ,,q.kF HNCpm D pߥN DOvDF pǿN QCp pOv 
]1964 ,Row and Harper :York New[ Philosophy Renaissance in Cosmos the and  
Individual The)

.53.p ,)1993 Summer( 3.No ,33.Vol ,u 
Psychology Humanistic of Jounal

:DOzJ

:PvC C oDOwV C ФC OhDܡFDO MDi

.22-409.,u Rejoinder A :Postmodernism of Signi q Huston ,Smith  
pp ,1995 July ,3.No ,12.Vol ,Philosophy andFaith

metanarrative .1

qCkpJp pO (1924) wCp w@@, Lyotard ]Francois-Jean .kz Ewe CpklWNDwJ

(1930) ǡOhDv F D GV pGo wCp CpklWNDwJ, Derrida ]Jacques { .3

deconstruction .4

challenges .5

.PvC Philosophy andFaith oDOhC PԵ , FP .6

modern .7

postmodern .8

scientistic .9

(17271642) wC G w DDo Newton ]Isaac Sir { .10

Wallace Alan .11

(1931) DpC kD w Rorty Richard .12

Eagleton Terry .13

terroristic .14

(18311770) DA w Hegel ]Friedrich Wilhelm Georg { .15

(19001844) DA w Nietzsche ]Wilhelm Friedrich { .16

(19761889) DA PwDwDOwrC w Heidegger ]Martin {.17

Caputo John .18

Anderson Walt .19

theory leaky a .20

Schroedinger .21

alterity .22

Nazi-Neo .23

Klan Klux Ku .24

Harris Randy .25

Constructedness .26

F rDV lpF ,(1915) DpC oDGN CkDD l@w@@ Bellow Saul .1976 ok MDFkC

.563?483?) PvC CkF A oCnDF l k Ϸ w@ Buddha (.

ego empirical the .29

PvC iz oClDJD rV XJ qC p ClvC qC kCp ,CkF A ok .Skand .30  
,lF :qC lNoDG rV XJ C .koA Cp Co kp kh DO OvJ @F 
.DA ,kCoC ,CokC ,uDwdC

pada-samut-pratitya .31

Dionysius-Pseudo .32

.(1925) DpC DF xF Fp pqDF Berra Yogi .33

.(19391865) lpC xD ,xDܡD ,pDz Yeats ]Butler William < { .34

.(19461874) wCp Dv DpC lw Stein Gertrude .35

.(19721885) DDOC Dv DpC pDz Pound ]Loomis[ Ezra .36

.lJCoqC Oz .37

xDo kD@@ Andrews Isabel Cicily oDOw D West Rebecca ]Dame { .38  
.(19831892) wC

Barth Roland .39

Kaleidoscopic .40

(19701879) wC xDo Forster ]organ[M ]dward[E .41

Spine .42

.(1941) DpC oD鲾De oDDqo Will ]Frederick[ George .43

niche-eco .44

pF koCk Pk ,PvC rDWGv Dܷ F ,߻ De qC , ,sC C .anatta .45  
,x ,oCllJ kV oߤ qC a xJ ok F ok ,C A ,CkF A lDõ ߤC qC 
.koCl kV pk oClDJ pV kV D ,MCm

.MDvwe D D ,l A ok . maya .46

.PvC rV kp u߿ D x ,l A ok Atman .47

.lzzo PDd F ߤ DCN lzzo MCm nature-Buddha .48

Man Universal .49

.(18271757) wC lp pDz Blake ]William { .50

Himalayas .51

Perspectivalism .52

.(18041724) DA w Kant ]Immanuel { .53

Constructivism .54

Rabin Jonathan .55

Harvey David .56

,oߤ ,op õ D DlC qC kCp ,PD w@@ D@@ ok ideas Mld lD) PzCk lCN CqC F D b xd D ok lCClkٲ@ 
.(kh

kV Co Od i Dh qC oD DϮ D PC DPd sunyat .58  
.DO Dh ;kz N l

Brahman Nirguna .59

MD A qC DpN DkV ldC ԵC lG ,D@N @@A ok Tao rN p qC pNCp pNpF Z , DOC vo vCF Ϯ D ;lpnJ 
.koCk zDeN DN l kV qC ,PvC rDN

Shankara .61

Nagarjuna .62

.(19511889) wC oDGN pNC w Wittgenstein ]Ludwig { .63

matter dark .64

,oD Dpk kz O DOvk v p F ,r@ ok detector < .65  
.lk D Co ... ,pW kC ,MCrϾ ,Dk

Lovejoy Arthur .66

Wilber Ken .67

Syracuse .68